Perhaps he is right. On the other hand, I very much liked his take on the legitimacy of atheism's critique of religion,Individual atheist writers and thinkers are more than happy to appear on the nation’s chat shows to promote their latest books. But they have failed to communicate a compelling vision of atheism that is capable of drawing large numbers of people and holding them securely. McGrath, Alister. The Twilight of Atheism (p. 269). The Crown Publishing Group. Kindle Edition.
I think Christians in the United States ought to carefully consider that remark. I recognize that not everyone intends we Catholics well. England has been horrible to Catholics in the past and is not very open to religion in general in the present. Yet, we ought to listen to what our antagonists think about us with an ear tuned in for the truth. We may learn something important. I highly recommend Dr. McGrath's fine book. Although not a co-religionist, we can learn much from him to the benefit of all Christians.But the real significance of atheism has to do with its critique of power and privilege. Whatever their failings—and they are many— atheist organizations are right in challenging the idea that any religious grouping can enjoy special privileges in a democratic society. Such groupings have a right to respect, but cannot expect to have influence beyond their demographically determined limits. When religion becomes the establishment, an abuse of power results that corrupts the worldview. When religion starts getting ideas about power, atheism soars in its appeal. McGrath, Alister. The Twilight of Atheism (pp. 275-276). The Crown Publishing Group. Kindle Edition.